Quick Summary: The Bombay High Court has canceled the decision to remove exam centers for several schools in Maharashtra, pointing out mistakes in the process and lack of proof for widespread cheating.
In an important decision made on January 19, 2026, the Bombay High Court listened to the complaints of several schools in Maharashtra. These schools, like Narsamata Secondary and Higher Secondary Ashram School, had their exam centers canceled by the Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education because of a cheating incident during the February 2025 exams.
On February 11, 2025, during the English exam, a student was caught cheating at one of the schools. This led to a notice in July 2025, questioning the school's ability to host exams. Even though the school explained that the cheating was a one-time event, the board canceled the center on December 18, 2025.
"The schools argue that this was just a one-time incident by one student."
The court, led by Judges Hiten S. Venegavkar and Vibha Kankanwadi, found the board's decision unfair and not well-explained. The decision to cancel was based on just one incident, not widespread cheating.
"Giving reasons is the most important part of making a decision... Writing down reasons is not just a formality."
The court pointed out the negative effect on students, who would have to travel 14 kilometers to another center, causing unnecessary trouble.
"The schools emphasize that many of their students already travel long distances."
The court canceled the orders to close the exam centers and told the board to reopen them for the upcoming exams. Schools must promise to ensure fair exams.
The court set rules to make sure future actions are fair and clear:
The court's decision highlights the need for fair processes and the importance of balancing strict cheating rules with fairness to schools and students. It aims to keep exams honest while ensuring schools are not unfairly punished.
