Bombay High Court: Orders New Probe in Sangola Urban Co-op Bank Loan Dispute

Quick Summary: The Bombay High Court has ordered a new investigation into a disputed loan case involving the Sangola Urban Co-operative Bank and several people, including Sonia Bhalchandra Godase. The court found that the previous decision didn't properly consider the defenses of the people involved.

Background: The Loan Dispute

The case is about a loan that Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and others supposedly took from the Sangola Urban Co-operative Bank. The bank claimed that Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and the others did not pay back the loan, which led to a recovery notice from the Deputy Registrar Cooperative Societies, Solapur.

Petitioners' Stand: Loan Never Given

The people involved, represented by Mr. Prasad Dani, argued that the loan was never actually given to them. They claimed that the bank made up fake documents and that Dharmaraj Borade, a bank employee, was involved in money lending activities. They also pointed out mistakes in the loan documents and interest calculations.

"The bank has made up fake loan documents," argued Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and the others.

Court's Findings: Need for Better Judgment

Justice S.G. Chapalgaonkar noted that the Deputy Registrar did not properly consider the defenses raised by Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and the others. The court stressed the need for a well-explained decision, as required by law.

"Giving reasons is an important part of fair decision-making," stated the court.

Respondents' Argument: Rules Were Followed

The bank, represented by Mr. V.S. Talkute, argued that all rules were followed and that Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and the others had other legal options available. They claimed that the legal actions were an attempt to avoid paying what they owed.

Court's Decision: A New Investigation

The court canceled the previous order and told the Deputy Registrar to conduct a new investigation. The registrar must look at all defenses and give a well-explained decision within four weeks.

What's Next?

Sonia Bhalchandra Godase and the other parties are set to appear before the Deputy Registrar on November 17, 2025, for the new investigation. The court's decision highlights the importance of following proper procedures and ensuring that everyone has a fair chance to present their case.