Madras High Court

Madras HC: Cosmos to Pay 50% of Tax for Case Reconsideration

Updated
Dec 28, 2025 11:01 AM
madras-hc-cosmos-to-pay-50-of-tax-for-case-reconsideration

Summary: Cosmos Purification Systems challenged a tax order from the State Tax Officer in Chennai, claiming they weren't given a fair chance to respond. The court agreed to reconsider the case if they pay half of the disputed tax amount.

The Case Begins: Cosmos vs. State Tax Officer

On December 5, 2025, Judge Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy heard a case involving Cosmos Purification Systems Private Limited. The company, led by Mr. Adithya Ravindranath, filed a complaint against an order issued by the State Tax Officer in the Sholinganallur Assessment Circle, Chennai.

What Went Wrong: A Missed Opportunity

The problem started with an order dated July 13, 2024. This order was about tax demands for the financial year 2019-20. Cosmos argued they weren't given a fair chance to present their case. They only found out about the order when their bank account was frozen.

"Cosmos Purification Systems was not provided a reasonable opportunity to contest the tax demands."

The Court's Decision: Pay and Proceed

The court acknowledged that Cosmos had filed the complaint late. However, considering the circumstances, Judge Ramamoorthy decided to give them another shot. But there was a catch. Cosmos has to pay 50% of the main tax demand within four weeks.

What's Next: A Fresh Start

Once Cosmos pays the required amount, the previous order will be canceled. The case will be reconsidered, and Cosmos will get a fair chance to present their side. The court ordered that a new decision should be made within three months after the payment.

Summary of the Verdict

The court's decision allows Cosmos Purification Systems to properly challenge the tax demands. This case highlights the importance of ensuring fair opportunities in legal proceedings.