Bombay High Court

Bombay High Court: Maki Modi's Property Dispute Requires New Hearing

Updated
Nov 11, 2025 6:54 PM
News Image

Quick Summary: Maki Homi Chibber, also known as Maki Modi, is in a legal battle with the State of Maharashtra over a property disagreement. The court has overturned a previous decision, and the case is heading back for a new hearing.

The Players Involved

Maki Homi Chibber, through her lawyer, is challenging the State of Maharashtra and several others, including a housing society and a construction company. The case revolves around a property in Thane, Maharashtra.

The Property Dispute

The conflict began when Maki's father acquired a large property in 1948. After he passed away, the property was transferred to Maki and her family. However, people living on the property claimed they had rights over a part of this land, leading to a complicated legal battle.

Lease and Construction Confusion

A lease was supposedly signed in 1981, giving building rights to a company. Buildings were constructed, and apartments were sold, but the legality of these actions was questioned. Maki argues that the lease was not valid.

"The Competent Authority granted a Certificate of Unilateral Deemed Conveyance...," which Maki claims was done without proper notice.

Court's Decision

Judge N. J. Jamadar found that the process was not clear and fair. The court noted that Maki wasn't given a fair chance to present her side of the story, leading to a decision being made without her input.

What's Next?

The court has ordered a new hearing to ensure all parties are heard. The case will be re-evaluated on November 24, 2025. The judge emphasized that the new hearing should not be influenced by past decisions.

Key Takeaways

  • The court highlighted the importance of following basic fairness principles.
  • Maki's main argument is that she was not properly informed about the proceedings.
  • The case involves multiple legal layers, including tenancy rights and property laws.