Bombay High Court

Bombay High Court: Fake Will Claim on Lady Jena Duggan's Estate Canceled

Updated
Sep 23, 2025 2:52 PM
News Image

Summary: A court case reveals a fake attempt to claim a valuable property in Mumbai through a forged will. The court cancels the fake claim, highlighting the trickery involved.

The People Involved

The case revolves around the estate of Lady Jena Jamshedji Duggan, who passed away in 1993. The main people involved are:

  • Vandana Janardhan Salve (formerly Vandana Feroze Duggan): A nurse claiming rights to the estate.
  • Bilkish Yunus Namakwala: Accused of fraudulently taking control over Lady Jena's property.

The Fake Claim

A Forged Will Appears

Bilkish Yunus Namakwala supposedly got a fake will dated April 6, 1993, claiming it was Lady Jena’s last will. This was used to take control over a property worth Rs. 150 crores at Malabar Hill.

"This case is a clear example of a major fraud committed... upon this Hon’ble Court."

The Legal Fight

Canceling the Fake Will

The rightful heirs, represented by lawyers including Mr. Aspi Chinoy, filed a request to cancel the fake Letters of Administration given to Bilkish. They argued that the will was made up and that Lady Jena had already made a real will on April 4, 1993.

Court's Decision

Judge Kamal Khata ruled in favor of canceling the fake claim, pointing out the trickery involved. The court noted how unlikely it was for Lady Jena to create a new will just two days after her real one.

Key Points of Dispute

Suspicious Situations

The court found it suspicious that the supposed will was not shown for 29 years and was only "found" conveniently by Bilkish.

"The delay... is very unlikely and lacks any proof or supporting circumstances."

Inconsistencies and Lies

Bilkish's claim of a mortgage and a loan to Lady Jena was not supported by evidence. The court pointed out the lack of any believable documents to back these claims.

Final Verdict

Cancellation and Results

The court not only canceled the fake Letters of Administration but also ordered that all related fake transactions be undone. It imposed heavy costs on Bilkish for her dishonest actions.

"The Letters of Administration granted in favor of the Respondent should be canceled with heavy costs."

Summary of the Verdict

The court decided to cancel the fake claim and undo all related transactions, punishing Bilkish for her dishonest actions.