Bombay High Court

Bombay High Court: Ashok Beharay's Petition Denied in Loan Dispute with Maharashtra Technical Education Society

Updated
Nov 17, 2025 12:41 PM
News Image

Here's a quick rundown: Ashok Shreekrishna Beharay tried to get involved in a loan application process of the Maharashtra Technical Education Society (MTES) but got denied by the court. Let's break down what happened.

Background: Who's Who?

Ashok Beharay used to be an important figure at MTES, a group that runs schools and colleges. He was the head of their Board of Control from 1999 to 2007. But things got complicated, and he was removed from his position in 2011. He says this removal wasn't fair and has been fighting it in court.

The Loan Drama

MTES wanted to borrow ₹10 Crore from Janata Sahakari Bank to finish building a school in Sangli. They needed permission from the Charity Commissioner, and that's where Beharay stepped in, claiming he should be part of the decision.

"The supposed Trustees have no right to make such a decision." - Beharay's claim.

Court's Decision: No Entry for Beharay

The Joint Charity Commissioner said Beharay didn't have enough connection to the loan matter to be involved. Even though there are many ongoing legal battles, the court decided his involvement wasn't necessary for this loan issue.

Arguments from Both Sides

  • Beharay's Stand: He argued that since his removal is still being contested, he should have a say in MTES matters. He pointed out past instances where he was allowed to get involved in similar situations.

  • MTES's Counter: They argued Beharay's actions were just to disrupt their operations. They highlighted that his removal had been confirmed in previous cases and that he was no longer a part of MTES.

Why It Matters

The court emphasized that the loan decision needed to be made quickly to avoid delays in the school project. Allowing Beharay to get involved could slow things down and turn the loan issue into another long court battle over who controls MTES.

Final Verdict

Justice N. J. Jamadar dismissed Beharay's petition, stating the Charity Commissioner should proceed with the loan application without Beharay's involvement.

So, the court decided it's best for MTES to move forward with their loan application without Beharay's interference.