In a legal battle between Amey Realty and Shree Construction, the court dismissed Amey Realty's case. The judge, Kamal Khata, found that Amey Realty's claims were filed too late and didn't have a strong reason to sue several other parties.
Amey Realty & Construction LLP, a partnership business, took on Shree Construction Company, another partnership business. The case also involved Bagwe Housing Private Ltd. and several people from the Pande family.
The main issue was about two Deeds of Surrender dated February 13, 2006. These deeds were agreements between Bagwe Housing Private Ltd. and the Pande family, which Amey Realty wanted to cancel.
Amey Realty argued that they had development rights on a property in Andheri, Mumbai, based on agreements from the 1990s. They claimed that the Deeds of Surrender, which took away these rights, were not valid.
Amey Realty's lawyer, Mr. Shah, argued that the deeds were made without their consent. He claimed the deeds recognized Amey's rights and should not have been valid without their approval.
Judge Kamal Khata pointed out that Amey Realty knew about the deeds by December 21, 2009, but only filed the case in 2016. According to the rules, they should have filed by December 2012. This delay was a key reason for dismissing the case.
Judge Khata concluded that Amey Realty had no valid contract with the Pande family or Bagwe Housing. The court found no direct relationship and dismissed the case against the Pande family and Bagwe Housing because the claim was too late.
The court emphasized that unnecessary lawsuits should be avoided and dismissed the case for being filed too late and lacking a strong reason to sue.
Amey Realty's request to pause the decision was also rejected, reinforcing the finality of the court's decision.
This case highlights the importance of taking legal action on time and having a clear agreement before going to court.
