Bombay High Court

High Court: Family Member Granted Preemption Rights in Land Dispute

Updated
Oct 17, 2025 10:38 PM
News Image

Summary: A court case about family land disputes and preemption rights under the Hindu Succession Act has been resolved. Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar was granted the right to acquire the land after a lengthy legal battle.

The Case Background

The case involves a family dispute over ancestral land in Ambajogai, Beed. Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar, son of the deceased Balkrushna, claimed his right to buy the land first before it was sold by his uncles and step-brothers, including Tukaram Rekha (Rekhu) Rathod.

The Legal Battle Begins

The legal fight began when Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar found out about the sale of shared family properties by his uncles and step-brothers. He filed a case, claiming his right to buy the land first under Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, which allows close family members to buy family property before others.

"Plaintiffs have the right to buy first." - Court Judgment

Court's Initial Decision

The trial court initially ruled in favor of Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar, declaring the sale invalid due to cheating and allowing him to buy the land by paying the sale amount within 90 days.

Appeals and Counterarguments

Both sides appealed. Tukaram Rekha (Rekhu) Rathod and the other defendants argued they were tenants and the case was filed too late. They also claimed Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar had no right under Section 22, as he knew about the transactions but did not act.

Final Judgment

The High Court, led by Judge Shailesh P. Brahme, agreed with the lower courts' decisions. It confirmed Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar's rights, stating he was a close family member, and required him to pay the purchase money with interest.

"The common judgment and decree passed... stands confirmed." - Final Order

Key Takeaways

  • Family Status: The land was considered shared family property.
  • Right to Buy First: Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar, as a close family member, was entitled to buy the land first.
  • Legal Procedures: The court emphasized proper steps for paying the purchase money and clarified that no extra time was given beyond what was legally allowed.

Summary of the Verdict

The court's decision confirms that Sham Balkrishnrao Selukar has the right to buy his family's land first, as long as he follows the court's conditions.