Bombay High Court

Bombay High Court: Detention Orders Overturned for Lack of Proper Consideration

Updated
Oct 5, 2025 7:46 PM
News Image

A recent court decision has overturned several detention orders in Maharashtra, finding them to have been issued without proper consideration of the law.

Background of the Case

The case involves multiple legal requests challenging detention orders under the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities Act, 1981. The person who brought the case, Saurabh alias Bhanja Ramswaroop Asajja, argued that his freedom was being restricted unlawfully.

Judges Involved

The decision was made by Judges Anil L. Pansare and Siddheshwar S. Thombre. They looked closely at the orders and found major mistakes in the process.

Important Parts of the Law

  • Section 3 of the Act: This part allows the State Government to detain people to stop activities that might disturb public peace.
  • Section 12: This part talks about confirming detention orders, which must be reviewed by a special board.

Problems with the Detention Orders

  • Issued Automatically: The court found that the orders were given out automatically without properly looking at individual situations.

"Such an order, in our view, is a classic example of what can be termed as a mechanical way to assess the situation."

  • No Good Reason: The State Government did not provide good reasons for approving the detention orders.

"The State Government has assigned no reason why the order passed by the District Magistrate, Yavatmal, has been approved."

The Court's Findings

  • Lack of Thought: The orders were made without properly considering the current situations, breaking the spirit of the law.

  • Role of Advisory Board: The court stressed the importance of the special board in actively reviewing detention orders.

"The Advisory Board must play an active role in ascertaining the legality of the detention."

Summary of the Verdict

The court overturned the detention orders, emphasizing the importance of following proper legal procedures and carefully considering matters that affect personal freedom. Saurabh alias Bhanja Ramswaroop Asajja was ordered to be released immediately unless he is needed for other cases.